It's one of the most common decisions landlords face, and it often gets made too quickly. A lease is coming up for renewal, and the first instinct is either to roll it over automatically or to wonder whether the market has moved on and a better tenant might be out there. Neither option is wrong, exactly. But both can lead to a decision that isn't quite right for the property or the investor's actual situation.
The smarter approach is to treat a lease expiry as a prompt to take stock. Not just of the rent, but of the whole picture.
Why Renewing a Tenant's Lease Deserves More Thought Than It Usually Gets
When a lease expiry comes around, the focus tends to land almost entirely on rent. Is the current figure still at market? Could the owner get more with a new tenancy? Those are fair questions, but they're not the only ones worth asking.
The thing to consider is what the current tenancy is actually worth in total, not just what it costs per week. A reliable tenant who pays on time, respects the property and communicates reasonably is delivering real value beyond the rent figure itself. That value tends to become most obvious when it's gone.
Before making any decision, it's worth reviewing a few things:
- Payment history. Has the tenant consistently paid on time, or has there been a pattern of arrears or late payments?
- Property care. Does the property come back from inspections in good order, or has there been ongoing maintenance caused by how the tenant uses it?
- Communication. Has the tenant reported issues promptly and been easy to deal with?
- Length and stability. A long-term tenant who knows the property, knows the neighbours and wants to stay has genuine worth.
A tenant who ticks all of those boxes is not easily replaced. The rental market can move quickly, and there is no guarantee that the next applicant will be as straightforward.
What Does It Actually Cost to Find a New Tenant?
This is where the numbers often surprise landlords. The gap between keeping a good tenant and going back to market can be larger than it first appears.
If a tenancy ends, the owner is typically looking at:
- A period of vacancy while the property is advertised and a new tenant is found. Even a few weeks without rent is a meaningful cost.
- Leasing fees, which vary depending on the agreement but represent a real outgoing.
- Marketing and listing costs.
- The time and effort involved in screening applications and processing a new tenancy.
- Potential maintenance or presentation work between tenancies.
Run those figures against the rent difference being considered, and the case for holding out for a higher figure can start to look less compelling. In practice, a modest rent reduction or a renewal at the current rate may leave the owner financially better off than absorbing vacancy and reletting costs in pursuit of an extra twenty or thirty dollars a week.
A Real-World Example: The Commercial Café Negotiation
This kind of thinking applies in residential and commercial property alike. A situation that illustrates it well involved a commercial café tenant that we managed facing a rent review. The instinct in that situation was to push for a higher rent, as you might expect. But when the full picture was considered, the economics looked different.
If the café tenant left, the owner would face a period of vacancy with no rental income coming in at all. Finding a replacement commercial tenant would involve marketing costs, leasing fees and substantial vacancy. There was also no certainty about how long that process would take, or whether the replacement tenant would be as reliable.
When those costs were weighed against the proposed rent increase, the better outcome was to negotiate a commercially sensible result that kept a good tenant in place. The owner ended up in a stronger financial position than they would have been had they held out for maximum rent and lost the tenancy entirely.
The bigger picture is that lease negotiations, whether residential or commercial, need to account for the true cost of turnover, not just the headline rent figure.
When Does Looking for a New Tenant Make More Sense?
Renewal is not always the right answer. There are situations where going back to market is the better call, and it's worth being honest about those too.
A new tenancy may make more sense if:
- The current rent is significantly below market and the tenant is unwilling to move to a reasonable figure over time.
- The existing tenancy has had consistent issues with payments, property care or communication that have not improved.
- The owner's circumstances have changed, for example, plans to sell, renovate or move into the property themselves.
- The property presentation has declined under the current tenancy and a full refurbishment between tenants is warranted anyway.
The goal is not to keep a tenant at any cost. It is to make the decision based on what actually serves the investment rather than defaulting to one option or the other without thinking it through.
Is Your Rent Still at Market?
One useful habit is to treat every lease renewal as a prompt for a property health check. Is the current rent still aligned with comparable properties in the area? Has the market moved since the tenancy began? What are similar properties achieving nearby?
This does not automatically mean pushing for the highest possible rent at renewal. Under current WA rules, rent increases are generally limited to once every 12 months, so timing matters. REIWA's guidance on renewing or ending a tenancy agreement is a useful reference point for understanding the process and your obligations as a landlord.
Checking the market figure gives the owner a clear basis for any conversation with the tenant, rather than guessing or assuming. It also means that if a rent adjustment is appropriate, it can be handled proactively rather than being left to drift well below market for years.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my current rent is still at market rate in Perth?
A property appraisal from an experienced local property manager is the most reliable way to check. They can compare your property against current comparable rentals in your area and advise whether a rent review is appropriate at the time of lease renewal.
What costs should I factor in if my tenant leaves?
The main costs to consider are vacancy, leasing fees, marketing and any maintenance or presentation work required between tenancies. Even a short vacancy period can offset several months of a higher rent, so it is worth calculating the real gap before deciding.
Can I negotiate rent with my existing tenant rather than going back to market?
Yes, and in many cases it is the more practical approach. If the tenant is reliable and wants to stay, a negotiated renewal can produce a better financial outcome than the costs and uncertainty of finding someone new. The starting point is understanding the current market rent and the true cost of turnover.
How often can I increase the rent in WA?
Under current WA rules, rent increases for residential tenancies are generally limited to once every 12 months. It is worth checking current Consumer Protection WA guidance before making any rent change, as rules in this area have changed in recent years.
What if my tenant wants to leave before the lease ends?
This is a separate situation from a lease renewal decision, and it involves different obligations for both the landlord and the tenant under the Residential Tenancies Act 1987 (WA). A property manager can guide you through the correct process depending on the circumstances.
A lease expiry is not just an administrative event. It is a genuine decision point, and the landlords who get the most from their investments tend to be the ones who approach it with the full picture in mind rather than just one number on a page.
Contact us to discuss your investment property and we can help you think through what makes the most sense for your situation.
